gavel and judge signing papers

How court watchers hold power accountable

Court watching is a way to have a tangible impact on the United States criminal justice system – without a law degree. Learn what court watchers do and why that’s important, what has been documented by them, and if this type of action might be right for you.

The first time I heard about court watching was at one of our meetings this summer: Michael, a lawyer and member of our group, told us about his experience representing clients at New York’s immigration courts. He mentioned how it makes a difference that there are volunteers who go to court specifically to watch the proceedings.

To learn more, I talked to Court Watch NYC, and they kindly pointed out more organizations. So if you want to become a court watcher, you’ll find contact information plus a sign-up link for a 2-part online training in October below. Please note that most organizations I found operate in New York City. That’s also where immigration-related hearings are held.

What do court watchers do?

They sit in a court room, and they take notes. The gathered information may later be used to expose problematic practices or to drive reform efforts. And court watchers’ presence alone often has an effect. Just imagine you suddenly had an audience – outfitted with pens and notepads, no less – at your workplace!

What’s the goal?

Court watching supports core principles in our democracy: transparency and accountability. Which is extra important in a political climate where due process guarantees seem to crumble. A judge may preside over dozens of cases in a single day at court. Often with massive consequences, but mostly unknown to the public. Court watchers help change that. From prosecutors to judges to the people standing before them, court watchers also send a message: The public is interested in what is going on in this court. It holds those in power accountable.

Does Court Watch NYC have a specific observation focus?

Yes. They focus on criminal courts, and they exclusively watch arraignments. And …

Wait: What’s an arraignment?
An arraignment is the first court appearance after a criminal arrest: It’s within the judge’s power to send the accused home, send them to jail, or to set bail. Click the little triangle to the left for more details!

After someone is arrested, they go before a judge for an arraignment: The judge tells the accused what they are being charged for, then sets a court date for the case. The judge also considers if the accused is likely to appear at their court hearing. It’s within the judge’s power to send them home, to jail, or to set bail – including the amount they have to pay.

In concept, bail money is an incentive to appear at the later court date. And a judge has to take into account whether the bail will pose “an undue hardship” to the accused and their loved ones. If they can’t pay, they go to jail until their court hearing. In New York, people who are not convicted, but accused of a crime are incarcarated at the infamous Rikers Island.

What kind of information do Court Watch NYC volunteers record?

They take down information about the charges against the accused, what the prosecutor asks for regarding bail or securing orders, what the defense attorney asks for, and then what the judge decides to assign.

Can you give examples?

Court Watch NYC has published several cases they documented. For instance, someone accused of stealing ice cream faced a 1,500 dollar bail. They watched a judge set a 20,000 dollar bail for someone accused of stealing razors and socks. They also documented a judge setting bail on a person despite acknowledging they had attended all previous court dates.

What else does Court Watch NYC pay attention to?

The group also watches certain judges that have been flagged by a partner project. Their concern is that these judges may not be following the law and seem extremely carceral, which means they seem to favor severe, prison-centered punishment.

What should prospective volunteers consider?

Court watching requires no special skills. However, watching court proceedings can be upsetting and make you feel sad. Court Watch NYC has a Slack channel for debriefing if necessary. Prospective volunteers should also know that Court Watch NYC is an abolitionist organization. In simple words: Their ultimate goal is for prisons to be gone. Volunteers can learn more about this background on their website.

Where, when, how often and for how long are volunteers expected to go court watching?

Once you’re trained, you’re free to court watch every day, or do it once a year – there is no ongoing committment. And the opportunities for watching are endless: Arraignments are held 24-7 in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx. Court Watch NYC also has a set of administrative tasks for volunteers which can be done from home, from going through the collected data to taking care of emails to trainings.

I’m intrigued! When is the next training?

Court Watch NYC offers 2-part online trainings once a quarter. Volunteers need to attend both parts. The next training start on Tuesday, October 14th, 2025, from 7:30 to 9:30 pm. Followed by Tuesday, October 21st, from 7:30 to 9:30 pm. Please sign up here.

What if I want to watch immigration courts, specifically?

There are at least two organizations who provide court support to immigrants at the courts at 290 Broadway and 201 Varick Street in Manhattan:

  • Immigrant ARC has a program called Friend of the Court. Volunteers assist with forms, answer questions and stand with immigrants during their hearing (more info and a signup form here).
  • The New Sanctuary Coalition’s accompaniment program trains volunteers to accompany people facing deportation to their immigration hearings and ICE check-ins. The goal is two-fold: moral support to the person facing deportation, and holding immigration authorities accountable. The organization also trains volunteers for so called “pro se clinics”, which are all about legal help (more info and a signup form here).

Posted

in

,

by

Tags: